Home | Magazine | Archives | Directory | Events | Testimonies | Prayerline | Links | Contact Us | Subscribe

... From the Goodnews archives, May/June 2003


 

The Challenge of the New Age


Pat Collins CM, a popular lecturer and retreat leader from All Hallows College in Dublin, reflects on the findings of "Jesus Christ, Bearer of the Water of Life: A Christian Reflection of New Age" recently published by the Vatican

 

Fr pat CollinsThe name, "New Age," has an astrological origin. According to its devotees we are about to leave the age of Pisces i.e. the Christian era, which has been characterised by a lot of violence. Instead we are now entering the Age of Aquarius, i.e. the era of universal religion, which will be a time of peace, harmony, and wholeness. The New Age movement, with its distinctive beliefs and practices, has become i ncreasi ngly influential over the last thirty years. It is hard to describe because it has no fixed creed or identifiable organisation. Someone has, rightly observed that understanding it is like trying to wrestle with a jelly As soon as you think you have got it under control, the shape of the whole thing changes and you have to start again.

As a priest I have noted different ways in which the New Age movement has been impinging upon the Catholic Church. For example, when I look at lists of forthcoming events in some retreat centres, it becomes apparent that a number of them, such asTi Chi, the Enneagram and Dream Therapy, are not of the traditional Christian kind, Many people contact me, by phone and in person, to ask whether I think modern practices such as aromatherapy Reiki healing, reflexology the Sila Method and Yoga are compatible with Christian belief. I have also noticed how some conservative and fundamentalist Christian writers are highly critical of anything to do with the New Age, seeing it as either pagan or diabolical in nature.

Perplexed about New Age, bishops and pastors have turned to Rome for help

Many bishops and pastors have, understandably been perplexed by all these developments. As a result, a number of them turned to Rome for help. They wanted answers to a number of questions. What exactly is the New Age movement? What are its distinctive beliefs and practices? To what extent is it compatible with official Christian teaching? Can the Church learn anything helpful from the New Age movement? Some weeks ago a discussion document entitled, "Jesus Christ the Bearer of the Water of Life:
A Christian Reflection on the New Age" was published by the Vatican. The authors say that it is an interim response, a sort of green paper It has two aims. Firstly, "it is an invitation to understand the New Age and to engage in a genuine dialogue with those who are influenced by New Age thought." Secondly it is "meant as a guide for Catholics in preaching the Gospel and teaching the faith at any level within the Church." Apparently when members of the Church have had an opportunity to offer feed-back on what it says, a final, more definitive version will be published.


Before I studied the document I wondered what tone it would be written in. I was reassured when I read: "It is essential to try to understand the New Age correctly in order to evaluate it fairly and avoid creating a caricature. It would be unwise and untrue to say that everything connected with the New Age movement is good, or that everything about it is bad." The document offers a well-informed, balanced and sympathetic description of the world-view informing the New Age movement. These are for example:


Core New Age Beliefs

  1. "The world, including the human race, constitutes an expression of a higher;
    more comprehensive divine nature.
  2. Hidden within each human being is a higher divine self, which is a manifestation of the higher more comprehensive divine nature.
  3. This higher nature can be awakened and can become the centre of the individual's everyday life.
  4. This awakening is the reason for the existence of each individual life."


The document concludes with a helpful glossary of 32 New Age terms, such as channelling, crystals, karma, Feng-shui and reincarnation, while briefly describing what each of them means.

Some good things in New Age

What are the main conclusions of the Pontifical document? Firstly, it sees the New Age movement as a laudable reaction to the materialism and rationalism of a good deal of western culture. Secondly, it is well attuned to the subjectivism of postmodern culture.Thirdly, it is attracting many people who are keen to have a meaningful spiritual life but who are disillusioned, for one reason or another; with the institutional churches. Fourthly rather than being a new phenomenon, it sees the New Age as a reappearance of ancient Gnosticism which talked, nearly 2000 years ago, about achieving salvation through higher states of consciousness. Whereas early Gnosticism synthesized Christian, Platonic and pagan beliefs, the New Age version adds in contemporary elements such as science, psychology and spiritualism. But just as many Gnostic beliefs were not acceptable in early Christianity so many New Age beliefs are unacceptable in modern Christianity.

Many New Age beliefs unacceptable to Christianity

The document notes many of the reasons why. Firstly God is not an impersonal energy as New Age thinking suggests. Secondly when the New Age says that, Jesus Christ is not God, but one of the many historical manifestations of the cosmic and universal Christ, it is quite mistaken.Thirdly whereas the New Age movement believes that we save ourselves by raising our levels of consciousness by using man made techniques, Christians believe, that we are justified by grace through faith in Christ and not by our own unaided efforts. Fourthly Christians reject the New Age notion of sin, which New Age sees as merely an imperfect form of knowledge which can be redressed by means of New Age methods.


Thankfully this very helpful document from Rome has identified the theological and ethical implications of the New Age movement and challenged its rejection of important Christian doctrines. However; it says that Christians need to avoid a prejudiced rejection of every idea and practice associated with New Age spirituality As "Jesus Christ the Bearer of the Water of Life" says:
"the relationship of the person, group, practice or commodity to the central tenets of Christianity is what counts." If you want to understand better the New Age movement from a Catholic point of view, you would be well advised to read this informative document which can be downloaded from the Vatican website at
www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/interelg/documents/rc_pc_interelg_doc_20030203_new-age_en.html